The whole contradiction between the Mattel audio file and the one that the Moms recorded is a real smoking gun. Mattel did something to change the audio JUST at the phrase Islam is the Light. Advancing Islamic dawah and then a cover-up.
Check out the back story here:
Parents complain to U.S. Agencies About Mattel “Islam is the Light” Doll
BOYCOTT MATTEL'S BABY DOLL TALKING DAWAH: "ISLAM IS THE LIGHT".
Combine Taub's work and Grayban's work and it's an interesting example of forensic audio investigation....:
OUR FINDINGS:
On October 13, 2008, Mattel posted - on their corporate webpage for “Investors and Media” - an audio file which they alleged was for the “Islam is the Light” sound made by the Little Mommy Real Loving Baby Cuddle & Coo doll.On November 18, Scott Grayban, a computer and audio expert, received an “Islam is the Light” doll directly from amazon.com, and recorded his own audio file using the methods described below. He compared it to the Mattel file posted at their website October 13, 2008.
Here are the two audio files:
The Mattel audio file: lil_mommie_coo_original_10k
The audio file recorded by Scott Grayban: my-sound.wav
As you can see, the two files are very similar - close to identical - UNTIL YOU REACH the section of audio for “Islam is the Light.” At that section, the Mattel file is very different from the Grayban file - and from the earlier parts of the Mattel file itself. FULL EXPLANATION BELOW:
Comparison: Mattel Website Audio vs. Actual Doll Audio
RECOMMENDATION: Further investigation is needed to determine if the file posted at the Mattel “Investors and Media” webpage was in any way altered from the actual sound made by the doll. If the sound is indeed different due to being edited or some other manipulation, other consumers and shareholders should ask for a formal investigation by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Based on Grayban’s tests, we are submitting a complaint and request for investigation to both FTC and SEC.Pending those official investigations, you can replicate Grayban’s experiment yourself, and we encourage any owner of the LMRLBCC doll to do so. We describe here the findings from this single experiment.
Please read it all. How nefarious...
