Blogger Interview with Tony Snow: Iraq
Joining me this afternoon to discuss the facts on the ground in Iraq was was Paul Mirengoff at Powerline, Lorrie Byrd over at Wizbang , NZ Bear Truth Laid Bear Ben from The Hill, Fausta, National Review, Tom Bevan over at Real Clear Politics, Rob over at Red State, Brian Weekly Standard for all.
Clearly the biggest problem the White House faces is communicating to the American people the advances and headway we are making in Iraq despite a mainstream media aligned with the terrorist force. But Snow made it clear we were in it to win and that was a mighty great thing to hear.
Listen to the audio here (run time 40 minutes): Download tonysnow712.mp3
The White House received the interim report looking at the state of affairs in Iraq."The whole purpose of the surge on the military side is to create enough stability and security so that there will be maneuvering room for the Iraqi government to be able to deal with sectarian tensions and regional tensions so that they can get about the business of doing political reconciliation and accommodation and passing a whole series of laws that not only going to build confidence but capability in the Iraqi government. But the military piece comes first....... Once you've done that you have the prospect of doing political success.
"Today's report indicates that the has been significant progress on the military front.
Military piece comes from first, you have got to go after the source of violence and military instability................. In this particular surge Political progress is not the leading indicator it is the lagging indicator............. today's report indicates that the has been significant progress on the military front..3 brigades into Baghdad. Significant decreases in violence............ Fairly remarkable turnaround in Anbar." Tribal chiefs had to make a choice - alqaeda or the allied forces. And so al qaeda has suffered significant damage.
"The purpose of benchmarks is not to find some political reason for leaving Iraq it is trying to come up with a framework for seceding in Iraq." Today the good news is on the security front there is significant progress, on the political front it's a mixed bag."
On the economic side, the Iraqis are stepping up..........
Ward asks, why is the motivation for Republicans that are defecting. Is it a framework for re-election. Tony was not going to try to interpret the motives of members of Congress.
Snow: "What is necessary in the next few months is a surge of facts ." (Yeah that's me in the background going yay!) A surge of true events on what is going on in Iraq today.
Snow: We will present good news and bad news but all that's been presented is bad news , it's a miracle that anybody supports the war based on the characterizations have been painted."
There's some real evil going on there. Americans need to get a sense of the kind of evil going on there. Humiliating Arabs and Muslims ...........slaughtering men women and children." Michael Yon's work bears hat out.
The concern is getting the word out to the American people so I asked why they didn't have bloggers at the White House press conferences and help to build this alternative highway to new media. In short, Snow said, because there are exactly 49 seats in the White House press room and the people that have those seats paid two million dollars for them. NEXT!
Tony Snow was emphatic that bloggers were very important in this fight. I followed up the question asking why the war was positioned as a separate issue when in fact it was very much a piece of the war on the global jihad.
He said, we need to plant a seed of freedom, it can have a profound effect. If we leave, al qaeda moves right in and has access to Iraq's wealth. It immediately becomes a destabilizing factor in the region. Surrounding nations will recalibrate their security plans ...... probably minimizing Americans role and maximizing dealing with al qaeda and iran. That is not good. Then it starts to emanate outward to Afghanistan, Pakistan ..........India. The thought that you walk away and the world suddenly becomes peaceful is wrong.
Snow said the only image Americans have of the war are caskets or people getting shot on the street.
Iraqis are taking 3 to 4 amount of casualties are we are.
Wizbang discussed politicians hedging and
Tom RCP - political poll on the party.
I did ask if the Navy pulling back in Persian Gulf emboldened Iran and decreased the pressure on them to stop interfering (and killing our soldiers.). He stated emphatically now, that "there were other means to pressuring Iran" but he was not at liberty to say.
I also asked him why Al Sadr was still alive (which met with knowing laughter) and Snow said we do not engage in assassinations. (If Al Sadr doesn't deserve a bullt, then who in my humble estimatiion.)
There's a lot to listen to, download it.
Fausta has a good recap here. Here's the Initial Benchmark Assessment Report on the surge, and the transcript of the President's press conference this morning.
Others in the call:
Lori Byrd of Wizbang, Red State, Rob Bluey, Military.com , ThreatsWatch, The Hill Congress Blog
The Weekly Standard's blog.
UPDATE: House Republicans
remained united on the Iraq vote today – with MORE Democrats voting against than
Republicans voting FOR.
Even Majority Leader
Steny Hoyer (D-MD) admitted that the Democrats’ bill was a political charade,
telling reporters yesterday that Democrats had to bring the bill to the floor to
pacify antiwar groups: “If we don't do anything, these groups will feel like
we haven't done anything.
Several key
facts:
- The bill passed by a
vote of 223-201.
- More Democrats voted
AGAINST the bill than Republicans voted FOR it.
- 10 Democrats voted
against the measure; just 4 Republicans voted for
it.
5 of the
Democrats who voted against the bill are from Chairman Skelton’s own committee –
the House Armed Services Committee (Reps. Boren, Ellsworth, Marshall, and two
subcommittee chairs, Reps. Snyder & Taylor)
Full vote breakdown
at this link: http://clerk.house.gov/evs/2007/roll425.xml
FINAL
VOTE RESULTS FOR ROLL CALL 624
(Democrats
in roman; Republicans in italic; Independents
underlined)
H
R 2956 YEA-AND-NAY 12-Jul-2007 6:13
PM
QUESTION: On Passage
BILL TITLE: Responsible
Redeployment from Iraq Act
----
YEAS 223 ---
|
Abercrombie |
Green,
Gene |
Neal
(MA) |
----
NAYS 201 ---
|
Aderholt |
Frelinghuysen |
Myrick |
----
NOT VOTING 8 ---
|
Berkley |
Davis,
Jo Ann |
Tancredo |
![Kurdistan](http://<a href="http://northerniraq.info" title="northern iraq"><img src="http://northerniraq.info/northlogo.gif" width="135px" height="68px" alt="northern iraq"><br>northern iraq </a>){kind=link}
Tony Snow is the American version of Baghdad Bob. His tortured logic becomes more comical every day. I find it interesting (and telling) that he was one of the first to publicly doubt that Bush was up to the job, yet readily sold his soul when offered the job. Scott McClellan was bad, but I think he honestly believed the words he spoke. Tony is perfectly aware that he is lying, aware that he is helping destroy our democracy, aware that this administration is the biggest enemy we face today, perhaps ever. But the pay is good and he gets his name in lights. You may disagree with my assesment, but you can't deny that he changed his opinion about the President and the war when he was offered the job. He has no integrity. Pathetic waste of protoplasm.
Posted by: Thrasher | Thursday, July 12, 2007 at 10:12 PM
Atlas, This is terrific! I'm glad the WH is acknowledging the vital role played by bloggers and reaching out for ideas. The bloggers are the heart of the battle. Bless all on the conference call. You asked the questions I would have asked, especially about the fat boy in Baghdad -- or Iran or wherever the hell he is today.
Posted by: x_dhimmi | Thursday, July 12, 2007 at 11:21 PM
Let me edit just a bit ... the military are our most shining heroes -- and their families. But conservative bloggers don't do it for love or money; they do what they do because of their deep love for their country and its citizens and for freedom.
Posted by: x_dhimmi | Thursday, July 12, 2007 at 11:24 PM
Pamela:
OT: more on our Tuber.
http://khattab.photoape.com/album/photo/index.cfm?albumID=8314&photoPage=74
He's Jewish!
Posted by: Jakesgramma | Friday, July 13, 2007 at 12:50 AM
sorry for posting in your comments here but i couldn't find a place to contact you. i came across this video today that i thought you'd enjoy. it's about a soldier support program called my soldier at manhattanville college in new york.
http://www.scribemedia.org/2007/07/13/my-soldier/
My Soldier takes the classic elements of being a pen pal and adds some modern commodities to make soldiers feel more at home, wherever they are.
Posted by: bmunch | Friday, July 13, 2007 at 05:19 PM