"Baked on the Premises.............pita" ATLAS EXCLUSIVE
Nidra is in Tel Aviv covering the Gaza Beach blood libel. Here is her seminal report, unedited. Only here in the Atlas sphere.
LET THE DEAD BURY THEIR DEAD
Nidra Poller
Tel Aviv June 14 2006
Eight Palestinian civilians are killed by an explosion on a Gaza beach and Israel is immediately accused, chided, chastised, rebuked …on the basis of a questionable news report from vaguely identified sources. Outrage is intense and close to unanimous. When, in the space of a few short days, the Israeli Defense Ministry produces the results of a serious investigation that clears Israeli troops of responsibility for the deaths, the media tamper with the evidence! In a sham of scrupulous caution, the IDF report is picked apart as if it were necessarily shoddy, while undue credibility is given to a lone expert, Marc Galasco, working for Human Rights Watch. Le Monde reports that the Israeli investigation is incomplete, suggesting it is half-baked, when in fact it will be voluntarily pursued to determine whether the accident was caused by buried Palestinian artillery or an unexploded Israeli shell aimed at rocket-launchers on a previous occasion. CNN-World reported Galasco’s “findings” as if they were Pentagon brand high-tech, only revealing his HRW affiliation hours later.
In the face of this perverse pussy-footing, a forthright reply is in order. Israel does not target sunbathing civilians. Israeli civilians are in fact targeted by an incessant rain of rockets fired from the recently evacuated Gaza strip. Israel attacks launching pads, launchers, and vehicles transporting rockets. If jihadis deliberately operate from the midst of civilian populations, what is Israel to do? What would you want your army to do if the rockets were landing on your house?
Reliable information was available from varied sources shortly after the initial broadcast of what looks like a Hamas-produced exploitation video passed off as news. A thorough scientific investigation has now been presented, countering allegations of Israeli guilt. To pretend that reasonable doubt subsists is simply dishonest. To claim that the Hamas version should be given equal weight with the IDF investigation is to abandon all notion of rational analysis and, consequently, all sense of reality. To maintain that we should give equal credence to both sides of the story is to engage in life-threatening mental contortions.
Every single Western media with a claim to integrity should not only publish a retraction of the unjust accusations thrown at Israel, they should explore their own readiness to pick up and relay these unfounded accusations. And, further, they should admit that the death of the Galia family and the grief of the 11 year-old orphan Huda were cynically exploited. The image of Huda running across the sand, discovering the dead bodies, throwing herself around hysterically, crying, and mouthing totally inappropriate accusations should be reviewed, cleansed of the twisted emotional impact it was designed to provoke, and studied as a stunning example of blood libel.
Nothing less than this is acceptable. And it should be understood that Israel is not the only victim of this manipulation. The target is much larger. It includes the entire Western world, our values, and our future.
What has happened? Instead of admitting the error and retracting the extravagant accusation, media and public officials have jumped on a June 13th incident in which Palestinian civilians were inadvertently killed in an aerial attack aimed at a truck transporting Katyusha rockets…to be launched against Israeli civilians. And somehow, in this ethical swamp of public opinion, the fact that many of these Katyushas and Qassams fail to kill is chalked up to the credit of the launchers. The Israeli attack is “murderous,” the terrorists are “militants,” and the rockets are “crude and unsophisticated”…about as harmful as spitballs.
Now Israeli officials are dancing on seven feet trying to prove that they are not evil monsters but decent people trying to protect their civilian population. They should be standing straight and tall and demanding an apology from public opinion and those who forge it.
How can such a bald-faced lie as the Gaza Beach Massacre get away with murder? Reliable information exists. The IDF scrupulously records, films, monitors, times, measures every single operation, every last shot. There is no ambiguity here. Nothing mysterious. No bone to gnaw on. Public opinion does not need to mull over the details, the shrapnel extracted from the bodies of the wounded, the size of the crater, the timing, the exact whereabouts of all six shells fired by an Israeli gunboat earlier that afternoon. The detailed report drafted by responsible officers of an honorable army serving a respectable democratic country should be accepted as given. The media should honestly explore their own guilt. And individuals should ask themselves how they were blinded by images of a child’s grief, and unable to think rationally about the story she was illustrating.
Falsified emotions and false accusations have seeped into the public mind, poisoning the heart, and incapacitating the logical facilities. Every journalist with eyes to see now knows that the “news report” included a spliced-in image of an Israeli gunboat, taken earlier that day, to give viewers the impression they were seeing the shell fired in real time, following it as it hits the beach, maims and kills, and creates a grieving orphan. Either these procedures are common practice or they should be denounced.
Huda has become an icon in the Arab-Muslim world, bringing to mind Mohamed al-Dura seminal icon of the jihad-intifada launched against Israel in September 2000. There too a crude enactment of a child’s suffering served as the emotional flash that obliterates rational thinking. The failure to come to grips with the al-Dura blood libel, despite the relentless efforts of analysts and investigators, has facilitated acceptance of the Sudaniya Beach version.
There is not a shred of evidence that Mohamed al-Dura was killed. [Myth, Fact, and al-Dura Affair, Commentary] Ample display of bleeding bodies and bloody garments corroborate reports that Palestinians were in fact hit by an explosion on a Gaza Beach on June 9th. Nothing indicates that they were, as France 2 Jerusalem correspondent Charles Enderlin said of Jamal and Mohamed al-Dura, “targets of fire coming from the Israeli positions.” But we see today that no amount of scientific proof can suffice to nullify this type of accusation. Unless and until they are recognized for what they are—blood libel. Irrational, exterminationist hatred of Jews. Unacceptable.









I for one am starting to understand what you have known for too long.
I started to understand when the American self haters and socialists began their attacks on Bush and everything associated with him, now even including "his" Military. Or at least what he and his warmongering buddy Rummy have done to our poor young kids in the Military.
I'm not so sure sometimes if we can survive this self destruction along with the impact of unlimited immigration and the active and passive aggression of the Islamics.
I'm afraid for my grandkids and that fear can make men do terrible things, even if and when they do not wish to.
Papa Ray
West Texas
USA
Posted by: Papa Ray | Tuesday, June 20, 2006 at 08:03 PM
Am I to understand that Israel has the 5th Column too??
Forgive me for not knowing this, but I thought Israel didn't have a bias liberal press, but based on this report...
Or is Nidra saying that the WORLD PRESS is neglecting to report the truth, that I DO KNOW...
Okay, I'll assume the Israel press IS not liberal and is reporting the facts, the truth. That the press is united with the people and doing their best to get the truth out, but it's being stiffled and ignored by the anti-semitic world..
We know CNN is anti-semitic, those fuckers continued to blame Israel for the sunbathers deaths for days after the truth came out...
From this report, it sounds like Hamas KNOWINGLY killed their own (again), then staged the propaganda video - again.
One day soon, we will rain holy hell on all these jihadists. It's coming, only after we or Israel takes another BIG kick in the balls. But it IS coming.. no doubt.
Posted by: Richard Davis | Tuesday, June 20, 2006 at 09:28 PM
Richard, The left in Israel is worse. They are suicidal. Land for terror and funding, bullets, etc.
The press, the parties - liberalism bespoils everything it touches.
Pamela
Posted by: Pamela Geller | Tuesday, June 20, 2006 at 09:33 PM
Atlas, this is really Dymphna. The Baron is signed in and my connection is sooo slow. Forgive the laziness.
Two things: I knew this was a crock the moment I saw it. Seldom that I post on something so immediately w/o waiting for more info but how long do we have to be acquainted with the behavioral sink called Palestine to believe *anything* they say. If they claimed the sun was shining, I'd still go to the window to check.
The only saving grace I can see for them is that they didn't DELIBERATELY shell their own people, which was my original suspicion. Glad to know it's simply the congenital stupidity arising from so many first-cousin marriages.
Second, I had planned to email you about this...I've been mulling over the disgraceful behavior of the mainline Protestant churches and their "poorpalestinians" broken record for several weeks now. The fever finally broke in a rant I left up at Gates of Vienna awhile ago.
Enjoy the high dudgeon since your words got me to thinking I had to put up some kind of response to the ongoing outrage about divestment. How clever not to call it a boycott. Institutional evil.
Here's my overdue rant:
American Protestant Pogroms
Posted by: Baron Bodissey | Tuesday, June 20, 2006 at 10:08 PM
Okay - thanks for letting me know. That's amazing.
I would have thought if ANY COUNTRY would be united, it would be Israel..
The fact that the press in Israel is a 5th Column is disappointing, to say the least, but only deepens MY resolve to fight to get America to WAKE UP.
Am REALLY looking forward to "WIDE AWAKE RADIO" - (perfect name btw) This country needs a wake up call.
I will spread the word best I can. Go clarion!
Posted by: Richard Davis | Wednesday, June 21, 2006 at 08:26 AM